New Book Summary: How Big Things Get Done by Bent Flyvbjerg and Dan Gardner


Why did the Sydney Opera House ruin its architect’s career? What can we learn about megaprojects from Pixar’s movies? My latest book summary is for How Big Things Get Done by Bent Flyvbjerg and Dan Gardner, which explores why so many megaprojects are disasters and how to prevent these failures.

As usual, the key takeaways are below, and you can find the full summary by clicking the link above.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Most megaprojects fail. Less than 1% of megaprojects come in on time, on budget, and deliver the claimed benefits.
  • Planning is essential to a megaproject’s success:
    • Megaprojects are typically rushed, with only superficial or slapdash plans. There’s often an action bias — people want to see “shovels in the ground”.
    • Some argue that we underestimate our creativity under pressure, and that planning just leads to paralysis. But the data doesn’t support this.
    • Others argue that planning obstructs creativity. However, the authors argue planning enables creativity as you can experiment during the planning stage, which is relatively cheap.
  • How to plan well — good planning is:
    • Broad. Start by asking what your goal is. Projects are a means to a goal, not a goal in themselves. Are there other ways of achieving your goal?
    • Slow and detailed. Detailed planning may be expensive in absolute terms, but cheap relative to delivery. You want to flush out as many problems as possible in the planning stage. Bad planning leaves problems to be figured out at the delivery stage.
    • Active. Planning is not just sitting and abstractly thinking about what you’ll do. It’s about making a model or simulation, testing it and refining it.
    • Risk mitigation. You can study the black swans that tend to come up in your type of project and plan for them. One way is to simply reduce the project’s duration, leaving less time for black swans to crop up.
  • Experience is underrated, usually for two reasons:
    • Domestic bias. Politicians prefer to award contracts to local companies to create local jobs, instead of outsourcing to foreign companies who have the relevant experience.
    • Uniqueness bias. We like words like “biggest”, “unique” or “bespoke”, but we should really be wary of them because anything unique is inexperienced.
  • The megaprojects that go wrong can go really wrong (the distribution is “fat-tailed”).
    • However, modularity can reduce risks. If you can break down your project into smaller, repeatable chunks, you can learn as you go and things won’t get too far off track even if you screw up.
    • Modularity is a matter of degree. Some people are now looking at ways to make traditionally non-modular projects like nuclear or hydroelectric dams more modular.

As usual, you can find the full detailed summary on the website. If you found this summary useful, consider forwarding to a friend that might enjoy it—especially if they're leading a megaproject!

Thanks for subscribing! Until next time,

To Summarise

ToSummarise.com

I summarise non-fiction books with more detail and critical analysis than you'll find elsewhere. Join my newsletter to get new summaries delivered straight to your inbox!

Read more from ToSummarise.com

Hope you've all had a good June. I've only posted 1 book summary and 2 blog posts: Book summaries Deep Utopia by Nick Bostrom (22 mins) — this weird book explores the question of what utopia could look like and what problems might be left after we've reached a state of technological maturity. Blog posts — both posts this month came about as I've been thinking and reading about the economics of AI. I'm planning to do a third post that will address that more directly, but these two lay the...

My latest summary is for Deep Utopia: Life and Meaning in a Solved World by Nick Bostrom, a former Oxford professor in philosophy. The books explores the question of what utopia could look like if technological progress goes as well as it possibly could, and what problems might still be left. As usual, the key takeaways are below, and you can find the full summary by clicking the link above. KEY TAKEAWAYS Bostrom explores what utopia could look like if we reached a state of technological...

After a month off in April, I got back to posting my usual 2 summaries this month: Book summaries The Art of Gathering by Priya Parker (23 mins) — an easy-to-read book with helpful advice on how to host meaningful social gatherings. The New Map by Daniel Yergin (28 mins) — a denser read that explains how energy security affects geopolitics and how the fracking boom and green energy transition have altered some of those dynamics. My next summary will be for Deep Utopia by Nick Bostrom, which...